If you’re thinking about selling, you could earn more than you'd expect. This guide will help you find the best places to sell old video games and consoles, both online and locally.
The Table of Contents
Why Sell Vintage Video Games?
Before diving into the where, let’s explore the why. Retro games bring a sense of nostalgia and charm that modern titles often lack. From simple graphics to timeless gameplay, they hold a deep emotional value for many gamers.
With the rise of video game trade-in platforms, it's easier than ever to sell your collection. Unlike crowded marketplaces, these niche sites attract buyers who truly understand the value of old games.
Platforms like these offer:
- Fast quotes and payments
- Options for selling single games or large collections
- Fair prices based on current demand
-
Ready to sell vintage video games for top dollar? See why we consistently pay 5-10x more than retail chains.
If you have rare games, complete-in-box items, or consoles in great shape, your collection could fetch serious cash. Plus, selling through trusted trade-in sites adds peace of mind thanks to their reputation and customer support.
Who Buys Old Video Games?
Online Marketplaces
Selling online connects you to a passionate community of retro gaming fans:
- eBay: Ideal for auctions or fixed-price sales with global reach. Use clear photos and detailed descriptions for the best results.
- Amazon: While Amazon has a vast marketplace, its trade-in program doesn’t support classic titles like Pokémon Emerald, NES, SNES, or other retro games.
- Etsy: Great for rare or unique titles. Etsy buyers often look for nostalgia and collectability.
- Specialized Marketplaces: Sites like The Old School Game Vault and Cash for Gamers focus solely on retro games and consoles. These platforms attract serious collectors and make selling fast and easy.
- Social Media (Instagram, TikTok): Build a following by showing off your collection. Use hashtags and engage through DMs for private sales.
Using a combination of these platforms can increase your visibility and help you get the best results.
Local Selling Options
Prefer to avoid shipping or want cash fast? These local options can help:
- Local Game Stores: Many buy retro games and offer cash or trade-in credit. Policies and pricing vary — call ahead to compare offers.
- Pawn Shops: Provide instant cash but often offer lower payouts. Negotiation is key.
- Flea Markets & Swap Meets: Great for selling in person to collectors. You can talk directly with buyers and get better prices.
- Craigslist & Facebook Marketplace: List games for free and sell locally. Easy to arrange meetups, no platform fees.
Understanding the Retro Gaming Market
Some games — like Super Mario Bros., Zelda, GoldenEye 007, and Pokémon Emerald — remain fan favorites decades later. Titles like Pokémon Emerald earned critical acclaim and still carry collector value today.
Key tips:
- Condition matters: Complete games with boxes/manuals sell for more.
- Timing counts: Sell near gaming conventions or during holidays to catch buyers when demand peaks.
- Stay informed: Join retro gaming groups to track market trends and high-value titles.
How the Platforms Stack Up
To help you sell vintage video games, we compared prices for five classic games:
- The Legend of Zelda – Nintendo NES
- Super Mario Kart – Super Nintendo
- GoldenEye 007 – Nintendo 64
- Jet Set Radio – Sega DreamCast
- Pokémon Emerald – Game Boy Advance
We focused this research on platforms that offer cash payouts (not just store credit), as explained in our.
What We Discovered:
- Gameflip and Swappa promote themselves as retro-friendly, but both function more like peer-to-peer marketplaces (think eBay). None of these five games could be traded in during this research. This means sellers have little chance on those platforms.
We checked both platforms to see if retro games like GoldenEye 007 and The Legend of Zelda were actually supported for trade-in.
Swappa had no active listings for GoldenEye, and GameFlip only had one overpriced NES Zelda listing for $1,000 — clearly not serious options for retro sellers.
- GameStop offered prices for most games — except The Legend of Zelda (NES) — but the offers were minimal. For example, they quoted Pokémon Emerald at $11.50, a steep drop from the game's actual market trade in value.
- GameStop offered prices for most games — except The Legend of Zelda (NES) — but the offers were minimal, see their trade-in portal here.
- The Old School Game Vault stood out by accepting all five titles and delivering the highest trade-in payouts across the board. Pokémon Emerald alone was valued at $108.10 — nearly 10x higher than GameStop.
The Bottom Line:
If you're a retro game collector or seller who wants real value for your classics, The Old School Game Vault is the logical choice.
Ready to Sell Your Retro Games for Cash?
Get fast quotes, real cash offers, and fair values from a platform built for collectors.
👉 Start Selling with The Old School Game Vault
The Wrap-Up — Why Try The Old School Game Vault?
Know what your games are worth, clean them up, and choose your platform wisely. At The Old School Game Vault, we’ve been buying retro games for over 18 years. We offer:
- Instant online quotes
- Fast payments via Zelle, PayPal, or check
- Friendly support for collectors and sellers
Whether you're selling a few games or a large collection, we make it simple.
Frequently Asked Questions: Selling Vintage Video Games
What is the best way to sell vintage video games?
- Specialized retro game buyers like The Old School Game Vault offer significantly higher payouts than retail chains—our research shows up to 10× more than GameStop for titles like Pokémon Emerald. Avoid peer-to-peer marketplaces like Swappa and GameFlip, which often have zero active buyers for retro titles despite marketing themselves as retro-friendly.
Are vintage video games worth money?
- Yes, many vintage games retain strong value—NES, SNES, N64, and Game Boy Advance titles especially command premium prices from collectors. Our comparison testing showed Pokémon Emerald worth $108+, The Legend of Zelda (NES) at $15+, and even common titles like GoldenEye 007 fetching real cash.
Does GameStop buy old/vintage games?
- GameStop accepts some retro titles but offers minimal payouts—they quoted $11.50 for Pokémon Emerald during our research, compared to $108.10 from specialist buyers. They often don't accept older classics like NES games at all, making them a poor choice for serious retro game sellers.
Is it better to sell games to GameStop or a specialist buyer?
- Specialist retro game buyers consistently pay 5–10× more than GameStop for vintage titles—our platform comparison showed GameStop paying $11.50 while specialists paid $108+ for the same Pokémon Emerald cartridge. Specialist buyers also accept a wider range of retro systems that GameStop won't touch.
Where should I sell old games?
- For vintage and retro games, use specialized buyers like The Old School Game Vault rather than general marketplaces—platforms like Swappa and GameFlip market themselves as retro-friendly but have virtually no active market for classic titles. eBay works for rare items you want to auction, but comes with listing work and seller fees.
Is there a market for vintage games?
- Yes, the retro gaming market is thriving with strong demand for Nintendo, Sega, and PlayStation classics—especially complete-in-box titles and rare releases. However, the market is concentrated among specialized buyers rather than general retailers, making platform choice critical for getting fair value.
What vintage video games are worth the most money?
- High-value vintage games include Pokémon titles (Emerald, Crystal), Zelda games across all Nintendo platforms, and late-release titles like Little Samson (NES) or Panzer Dragoon Saga (Saturn). Condition matters significantly—complete-in-box games with manuals sell for 3–5× more than cartridge-only copies.
