Sell Your N64 Games Online for Cash
Most trade-in sites pay store credit. The Old School Game Vault pays cash. We have been buying used N64 games since 2008, with an A+ BBB rating and a 4.99 score on Trustpilot. We buy all the old Nintendo 64 games, including Super Mario 64, GoldenEye 007, and rare finds like Conker’s Bad Fur Day and ClayFighter: Sculptor’s Cut.
Every N64 trade-in is checked for authenticity. Counterfeit N64 cartridges are one of the most common fakes we see, especially on online marketplaces. If you are unsure about your game, read our article on how to spot counterfeit N64 cartridges before submitting your trade-in.
Frequently Asked Questions
▶ How do I sell N64 games to The Old School Game Vault?
Find your Nintendo 64 games in our catalog, listed in alphabetical order, or use the search tool to find a specific game by name. Once you find your game, click the "Sell It" button to add it to your trade-in cart.
Once your order totals $100 or more, you can check out and submit it. We issue payment within 3 to 4 business days of receiving your order. We pay cash, not store credit, via Zelle, PayPal, check, or gift cards.
▶ Do N64 games need to include the original box and manual?
No, all N64 trade-in prices listed are for the game cartridge only.
▶ Do you only buy NTSC N64 games?
Yes, we only buy NTSC-U (U.S.) N64 games.
Full details about condition requirements, shipping, and payment are available in our policy pages linked below.
Other Nintendo Cartridge Console Trade-In Options
NES Games | NES Systems | Super Nintendo Games | Super Nintendo Systems | Nintendo 64 Games | Nintendo 64 Systems
The Old School Game Vault
Shipping Address: 6321 W. Dempster St #261, Morton Grove, IL 60053
Phone: +1 (847) 461-8568
