Selling Guide – Where to Sell Video Games Online for Fast Cash on Retro Games

Looking to sell your old video games online for fast cash? Whether you have retro cartridges, classic discs, or entire console collections, knowing where to sell makes all the difference.

This Quick Answer guide breaks down the best online places to trade in your video games and get paid quickly—including how The Old School Game Vault offers fast payouts with no listing hassles.

The Table of Contents

Start Selling Your Games Now

Not every platform gives your collection the value it deserves. Some sites undervalue rare games, and others make the process slow or frustrating. If you're unsure what your old games are really worth, sites like PriceCharting track current market prices for thousands of retro titles.

In this article, I will tell you the best places to sell video games. I will share my own experience and explain how you can make some money and clear out space easily.

So, is it time to sell my retro games for some extra cash?

I used to hang onto every game I finished—telling myself I’d replay it or lend it to a friend. That might’ve been true for the first year or two, but decades later? Not so much.

Now in my forties, I’m still holding onto a lot of the video games I grew up with. Heck, I still have my original Nintendo NES sitting in a box. 

Let’s be honest, nobody is asking to borrow my 1985 copy of Super Mario Bros. or my 1992 copy of Mario Kart anymore.

There are gamers and collectors out there who would love these classic titles. But unless I put them on the market, they’re just gathering dust. And to be real, I’m not booting up Mario Golf or Donkey Kong Country any time soon. They were great in their day—but they don’t quite hold up for me now.

My Old Video Games Are Taking Up Too Much Space

Why do I keep retro video games that I never play? I think of my game shelf like my fridge, filled with things I might use later. But, like leftovers, most of it just stays there and takes up space. And the value of these games? Sadly, they don't improve over time like wine.

Sure, some rare titles gain value over time. But most old video games lose worth the longer you wait. If you’re not going to play them, you might as well sell them while they’re still in demand.

Sorting Through My Old Games

While writing this post, I finally went through my collection and pulled out games I knew I'd never play again. Titles like Mario Kart, Donkey Kong Country, Super Mario RPG, and Street Fighter II, all great memories, but no longer part of my rotation.

That first stack felt like a win. I could sell these video games for cash, free up shelf space, and make a little money in the process. But once I got going, it was hard to stop.

I did a second run, this time adding my old Nintendo 64 copy of Super Mario 64., a few Pokémon DS games, and even I had a 3DS game that my wife no longer played. I asked her about it first, as communication is important in a marriage. Selling it cleared up some space and added a bit more money to my total.

Being Honest About What I’ll Actually Replay

Finally, I made one last pass. I pulled games I still liked—but realistically wasn’t going to replay. Between emulation, modern collections, and the Nintendo Switch library, I had new ways to enjoy those classics. There was no reason to let these vintage video games sit idle.

Even accessories got the axe: my SNES controller, GameCube controller, and NES gear were all added to the pile. With retro consoles and games now re-released or emulated, I didn’t need to hang on to the originals.

By the end of this third round, I had over 20 games ready to go. What began as "maybe I can earn some money" turned into over $100. That amount is enough to buy a good used game or save toward a new console.

What Makes a Game Buyer Trustworthy?

I talked with some friends who have sold games. A few of them used Facebook Marketplace. Others tried different websites. I was surprised to learn that a few got good prices from independent online game stores. That piqued my curiosity.

I did what anyone would: I Googled “where to sell retro games near me” and got dozens of results. Many of the lists for the "best places to sell video games" seemed sponsored or out of date.

One example is this Lifehacker article, which includes familiar names like Decluttr, but those options often don’t offer much real value. Decluttr was mentioned often, and I will explain more about them shortly.

Why You Need to Compare Game Trade-In Sites

Let me be blunt: not all trade-in websites are worth your time. I tested Decluttr with two GameCube games — Mario Golf and BloodRayne. The offer? $0.32 each.

Seriously—three dimes and two pennies. You can see the full breakdown in our Decluttr vs The Old School Game Vault comparison, where we show real quotes and why we pay more.

It made me wonder: how do you even sell video games that predate that system—especially when they don’t have barcodes? If you’re having trouble pulling up certain games, check out our keyword search tips to learn how to find titles faster using correct punctuation and platform codes.

Why I Chose The Old School Game Vault

Eventually, I found The Old School Game Vault. It stood out right away. The website was easy to use, the video game trade-in prices were fair, and I could even sell gaming consoles and accessories.

I emailed to ask about shipping and fees. They responded fast, orders over $100 get a free prepaid shipping label. That sealed the deal.

Why The Old School Game Vault is the Better Choice

The Old School Game Vault provides several payment options: PayPal, Zelle, or check. I selected direct deposit through Zelle. Once I shipped my games, I was paid within a week. And yes, I heard directly from Brandon throughout the process. It felt personal.

Now my shelf is clean, I’ve got cash in my account, and those games are off to someone who’ll enjoy them again. If you’re asking yourself whether it’s time to sell your old video games online—the answer might be yes.

Cash or Store Credit?
Many platforms default to store credit, but that’s not always in your best interest. Read our guide on Cash vs Store Credit – Which Pays More for Used Games to understand how each option stacks up.

The Old School Game Vault was built for retro gamers. We specialize in NES, SNES, GameCube, PS1, PS2, and other classic systems—and we pay based on real market value, not barcode scans or auction listings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do people still buy old video games?

• Absolutely. Collectors and retro gamers are always looking for classics like NES, SNES, PS2, GameCube, and more.
• Some titles even increase in value over time, especially complete or mint-condition games.

What retro games are worth the most?

• Rare titles, RPGs, and franchise games like Pokémon, Zelda, Final Fantasy, and EarthBound often retain or grow in value.
• Sites like PriceCharting.com can help you check current prices.

Where can I sell retro games near me?

• Even if you search “where to sell retro games near me,” many top platforms are online-based.
• The Old School Game Vault lets you ship your games from anywhere in the U.S. and offers prepaid shipping on qualifying orders.