6321 W. Dempster St #261, Morton Grove, IL 60053 +1 (312) 423-6583

Sell Your N64 Games to America's Top-Rated Buyer

Sell your Nintendo 64 games to America's top-rated video game buyer - rated 4.99★ on 1,600+ reviews since 2008. We buy all N64 cartridges from common titles like Super Mario 64 and GoldenEye 007 to rare collectibles like ClayFighter Sculptor's Cut and Conker's Bad Fur Day. Get your instant quote today, receive a free shipping label, and get paid within 48 hours via PayPal, Zelle, or check.

Boxed Nintendo 64 console with controllers and AV cables ready for trade-in
Sell N64 Console & Accessories

🎮 Selling N64 Games – Frequently Asked Questions

 

Where can I sell N64 games for the best prices?

  • The Old School Game Vault offers the best prices for N64 games online. Rated 4.99★ on 1,600+ reviews, we pay more than GameStop trade-in and have no seller fees like eBay (15%) or Gameflip (10-15%). Get cash not store credit!

Do Nintendo 64 games need to include the original box or manual?

  • No, our prices are for the game cartridge only. We buy loose N64 cartridges. Complete-in-box games with boxes and manuals usually fetch premium prices on the collector market, but our quotes are based on the cartridge itself.

What Nintendo 64 games don't you buy?

  • We only buy NTSC-USA Nintendo 64 games. We don't buy games with torn labels, games covered in stickers, or games with permanent marker writing. Light wear is acceptable, but labels must be intact and legible. Please shoot us an email if you have any questions.

How do I sell my N64 games to The Old School Game Vault?

  • Use our quote tool to search for your Nintendo 64 games and get instant offers. After submitting your list, we'll email you a free prepaid shipping label. Pack your N64 cartridges securely, ship them to us, and get paid within 48 hours.

What is the best platform to sell N64 cartridges?

  • The Old School Game Vault is the best platform to sell N64 cartridges online. Unlike eBay (15% seller fees), Gameflip (10-15% fees), or DKOldies (store credit), we offer instant cash quotes with no fees, free prepaid shipping labels, and payment within 48 hours. Rated 4.99★ on 1,600+ reviews since 2008.

What fees should I expect when selling N64 games online?

  • At The Old School Game Vault, there are ZERO fees. You keep 100% of your quoted price. By comparison, eBay charges around 15% seller fees plus payment processing, Gameflip takes 10-15%, and other platforms charge listing or transaction fees. We provide free shipping labels and pay you the full quoted amount via PayPal, Zelle, or check.