Where can I sell my N64 games online?

 
You can sell N64 games online to The Old School Game Vault, a nationwide mail-in retro video game buyer operating since 2008. We display our current cash offer for each game upfront, so you know what we offer before you place your order. We pay cash, not store credit, with no seller fees. Every price below is for the game cartridge only.
Boxed Nintendo 64 console with controllers and AV cables.
Sell N64 Console & Accessories

How much can you sell N64 games for?

The Old School Game Vault lists a current cash offer for each Nintendo 64 game it buys. Listed prices are for the cartridge alone, with the final payment subject to condition and authenticity checks.

More details
  • We buy old Nintendo 64 games from across the library, including Super Mario 64 and GoldenEye 007, plus rare finds like Conker's Bad Fur Day and ClayFighter: Sculptor's Cut.
  • Every N64 trade-in is checked for authenticity. If you are unsure about your game, read our article on how to spot counterfeit N64 cartridges before submitting your trade-in.

How to sell N64 games?

To sell N64 games, find each game in our catalog, add it to your trade-in order, and ship your order to us. We check every game and pay you in cash, not store credit.

More details
  • Browse the full alphabetized list or search by name to find your games. You'll see our cash offer for each cartridge and your order total before shipping anything to us.
  • Shipping and payment details are covered in the questions below.

Sell Other Nintendo Games

Before the N64 came the NES, SNES, and Virtual Boy. Pick one to see what we pay, or browse all Nintendo platforms.

N64 Selling Questions

Answers to common questions about selling your N64 games.

▶ Do I need the box and manual to trade in my N64 games?

No. All N64 game prices in our catalog are for the cartridge only. Original boxes and manuals are not required, but they are always welcome.

▶ What if I haven't tested these games in years?

That's fine. We clean the cartridge contacts before testing each game to give it the best chance of working. Games that still don't work after cleaning and testing will be rejected.

▶ What happens if my N64 games are rejected?

We'll email you to explain which games were rejected and why. You can choose to have them recycled or returned to you. You're responsible for the shipping cost if you want rejected games returned.

▶ What affects a game's trade-in value?

Demand and rarity help determine our listed buying price, while condition affects whether we can pay that offer. Badly torn labels or stickers that make the game's label barely visible can lead to rejection. Storage conditions also matter: we don't purchase games with rusted screws or circuit boards.

▶ What is the best way to ship N64 games safely after selling?

Pack your N64 games in a sturdy box with three inches of cushioning on the top, bottom, and all sides. Pay particular attention to the bottom of the box, and fill empty spaces so the cartridges cannot shift during shipping.

▶ How do I get paid for my N64 games?

You'll receive payment within 3 to 4 business days after your order is received and processed, by PayPal, Zelle, Venmo, Apple Cash, check, or Amazon Gift Card. Orders over $100 also receive a free shipping label.

▶ Can I buy Nintendo 64 games from you?

Yes. You can buy N64 games in our online retro video game store.

Why Sell Nintendo 64 Games Online to The Old School Game Vault?

We pay cash for your N64 games, not store credit, with no seller fees. We hold an A+ BBB rating and have a 4.99-star average from more than 300 reviews on our website. Any condition deductions are explained on our Payment & Deductions page.