Selling Guide – How to Sell Old Video Games with The Old School Game Vault

Got a box of old video games collecting dust? Now's the time to cash out! If you want to sell your old games—or ones your kids don’t play anymore—The Old School Game Vault makes the process quick and easy.

With over 18 years of experience in retro gaming, we’ve helped thousands of sellers get paid fast, whether it’s NES cartridges or Nintendo Switch games.

Below is a step-by-step guide on how to sell video games for cash with The Old School Game Vault.

✅  Selling Your Games in 4 Steps

✔️ Get an instant quote by searching your game’s name—no barcode required
✔️ Add your games, consoles, or accessories to the trade-in cart
✔️ Ship your items (we provide free shipping over $100)
✔️ Get paid fast by Zelle, PayPal, or check after inspection

The Table of Contents

Step 1: Get an Instant Quote for Your Games

Head over to our Sell Video Games page. Just type the name of your game into the search bar, no barcode or photos required. You’ll instantly see our current trade in price.

🎮 We buy games from nearly every major system:

• Nintendo: NES, SNES, N64, GameCube, DS, 3DS, Switch, Wii
• Sega: Genesis, Saturn, Dreamcast
• PlayStation: PS1, PS2, PS3, PSP
• Xbox: Original Xbox, Xbox 360
• Plus rare consoles like NeoGeo, TurboGrafx-16, and Atari

⚠️ We no longer accept PC games or Wii consoles, but we do buy Wii games.

Step 2: How to Add Games, Consoles & Accessories to Your Trade-In Cart

Selling Individual Games

1. Start at the Trade-In Cart.
2. In the search bar, type the full game title + system abbreviation (e.g., Final Fantasy VII PS1).
3. Click Search, then hit Sell It Now when the correct listing appears.

Trouble finding your game in search?

Make sure you're using the correct console abbreviation, full game title, and proper punctuation. For step-by-step help, check out our keyword search tips guide — it’ll show you how to pull up titles faster and avoid common mistakes like using abbreviations or missing apostrophes.

Selling a Large Game Collection

If you’re trading in multiple titles for the same console:

1. Visit the platform’s specific page (e.g., Sell NES Games).
2. Use the “Show” dropdown to display 50 results per page for easier browsing.
3. Scroll through the listings and click Sell It Now next to each game you want to trade.

Selling Consoles (Example: PS2 Slim Console Bundle)

To sell a full PS2 console setup:

1. Go to Sell PlayStation > Sell PS2 Games > Sell PS2 Console & Accessories.
2. Look for:
3. (PlayStation 2, PS2): Slim Black Console Bundle, System
4. To receive the full $50 value, your bundle should include:

• ✅ PS2 Slim Console
• ✅ AV Cable
• ✅ AC Adapter
• ✅ Memory Card
• ✅ One official DualShock 2 controller

🚫 Third-party accessories are not accepted.

1. Missing any components? Use the checkbox system to adjust:

• Controller: -$6.00
• AV Cables: -$1.50
• AC Adapter: -$5.00
• Memory Card: -$1.50

1. Click Sell It Now to lock in your adjusted value.

Selling Accessories

1. Head back to the Console & Accessories section for your platform.
2. Scroll through the list and click Sell It Now for each accessory you're selling.

Step 3: Ship Your Games

After placing your order, we’ll email you a confirmation and shipping instructions.

📦 If your order totals $100 or more, we’ll include a free USPS prepaid shipping label or UPS Ground label.

Local to Chicago? You can drop off your order at our Morton Grove location, but you need to make an appointment first.

Packaging Tips:

• Use bubble wrap or foam to protect games in transit
• Include your printed order confirmation inside the box

Step 4: We Inspect & Pay Fast

Once your package arrives, you’ll receive a “Package Received” email. Within 24–48 hours, our team will:

• ✅ Inspect each item for condition and completeness
• ✅ Then test each game or console for functionality
• 🕒 Please note: We do not test or process orders on weekends or holidays.
• For example, if your package arrives on Friday, your payment will typically be issued by Wednesday of the following week.

🔗 Learn more:

How We Pay You – Trusted Payment Options for Selling Video Games

💰 Payment options include:

• Zelle
• PayPal
• Physical check

⭐ Trusted by Thousands of Gamers

Read verified customer reviews on Trustpilot

💬 Trusted by top personal finance sites like Making Sense of Cents, The Old School Game Vault is often suggested as one of the top places to sell retro video games.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How do I trade in my video games at The Old School Game Vault?

• Trading in your games is easy. Just search for the titles you want to sell on our Sell Video Games page, add them to your trade-in cart, and submit your order.
• Once your package arrives, we inspect and test each item, then send your payment fast, via Zelle, PayPal, or check.

How much are old video games worth?

• The value of old video games depends on condition, platform, rarity, and demand. Popular retro titles can fetch $20–$100+, while rare or complete-in-box games can go for much more.
• You can check real-time offers using our instant quote tool—no barcode required.

Do you offer a video game trade-in value calculator?

• Yes! Our search tool functions like a trade-in value calculator. Just type in your game’s name and system, and you’ll instantly see the trade-in price—no photos, barcodes, or listings required.

Can I sell my old video game consoles too?

• Absolutely! We buy a wide range of retro and modern systems—from NES, SNES, PS1, and Sega Genesis to newer consoles like the Nintendo Switch.
• To get started, visit the Sell Consoles page listed under each platform in our Sell Video Games section and add your hardware to the cart.
• Please include all necessary parts to get the full value.

Ready to Turn Your Old Games into Cash?

Skip the hassle, skip the barcode scanning—and get paid fast with The Old School Game Vault.

👉 Get Your Instant Trade-In Quote Now